Report on Conversion Practices in Africa: Strategic Litigation and Multi-Sectoral Responses
A comprehensive and robust advocacy strategy against conversion practices in Africa:
**Introduction:**
Conversion practices, also known as “conversion therapy,” are harmful practices aimed at changing an individual’s sexual orientation or gender identity. In Africa, these practices persist due to deep-rooted social, cultural, and religious beliefs that stigmatize LGBTQ+ identities. Addressing this issue requires a multifaceted approach, combining legal frameworks, strategic litigation, advocacy, health interventions, and education.
This report provides an overview of conversion practices in Africa and outlines key strategies for combating these harmful practices through legal action, cross-sector collaboration, and targeted interventions.
**Strategic Litigation and Legal Approaches:**
Legal strategies play a pivotal role in challenging and dismantling conversion practices. Strategic litigation has successfully challenged discriminatory laws across Africa, setting important precedents that can be applied to end conversion practices.
Key examples include:
- **Uganda's Anti-Homosexuality Act:** The Constitutional Court struck down this law, demonstrating the effectiveness of legal challenges in overturning repressive legislation.
- **African Human Rights Instruments:** Utilizing the African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights Resolutions 275 and 552, which explicitly call for the protection of sexual minorities, is essential in framing the fight against conversion practices within the broader human rights agenda.
**Recommendations:**
- **Country-specific strategic litigation efforts**: Identify countries where legal challenges can be initiated using constitutional guarantees, human rights frameworks, and international treaties.
- **Engagement with African human rights institutions**: Push for accountability and enforcement of resolutions aimed at protecting sexual minorities.
- **Legal protections for LGBTQ+ activists and allies**: Advocate for stronger legal protections for those who face harassment or threats due to their activism against conversion practices.
**Mental Health and Trauma Support:**
Conversion practices often leave survivors with profound psychological trauma. Despite being framed as “therapeutic” or “corrective,” these practices exacerbate mental health issues, leading to depression, anxiety, and in extreme cases, suicide.
**Recommendations:**
- **Specialized trauma care programs:** Develop and implement mental health programs specifically tailored to survivors of conversion practices.
- **Inclusion of LGBTQ+ affirmative care in health systems**: Encourage governments to integrate mental health services that affirm LGBTQ+ identities into public health frameworks.
- **Partnerships with mental health organizations**: Establish collaborations with local and international mental health organizations to provide continuous care for survivors.
**International Support and Pressure:**
While legal efforts at the national level are critical, international support and pressure can accelerate change. Countries that continue to allow conversion practices often rely on foreign aid, international trade agreements, and diplomatic relationships, making them vulnerable to external influence.
**Recommendations:**
- **Leveraging international mechanisms**: Engage the United Nations, the African Union, and other global human rights bodies to put diplomatic pressure on African countries permitting conversion practices.
- **Sanctions and aid conditions**: Call on international partners to include LGBTQ+ rights conditions in aid and trade agreements with countries where conversion practices are widespread.
- **Diplomatic advocacy**: Use diplomatic channels to raise awareness and encourage African leaders to adopt more progressive, human rights-centered policies.
**Intersectionality and Vulnerable Populations:**
LGBTQ+ individuals often face additional layers of discrimination based on gender, socioeconomic status, disability, or refugee status. This intersectionality compounds the challenges faced by those targeted for conversion practices.
**Recommendations:**
- **Inclusive policy frameworks**: Advocate for laws and policies that protect LGBTQ+ individuals, particularly those who are part of other marginalized groups.
- **Engagement with intersectional activists**: Build coalitions with feminist, disability, and refugee rights groups to develop comprehensive strategies that address the unique vulnerabilities of specific LGBTQ+ sub-groups.
**Monitoring, Accountability, and Enforcement:**
Even after passing laws to ban conversion practices, enforcing these laws can be a challenge. Establishing mechanisms for monitoring and reporting violations is critical to ensure accountability.
**Recommendations:**
- **Independent watchdogs**: Create independent bodies or task forces to monitor the enforcement of laws against conversion practices.
- **Reporting hotlines**: Establish anonymous reporting mechanisms for individuals who have experienced or witnessed conversion practices.
- **Collaboration with civil society**: Work closely with NGOs and LGBTQ+ organizations to document and report violations, ensuring that evidence is gathered for legal action when necessary.
**Case Studies and Survivor Testimonies:**
Including case studies and survivor testimonies can humanize the issue and highlight the severity of the harm caused by conversion practices. Personal stories can provide a powerful emotional appeal to complement legal and policy arguments.
**Recommendations:**
- **Document survivor stories**: With consent, document and share testimonies from survivors to raise awareness about the mental, physical, and emotional damage caused by conversion practices.
- **Incorporate survivor voices in advocacy**: Ensure survivors are at the forefront of advocacy efforts, using their lived experiences to drive change.
#### **Youth and Educational Programs:**
LGBTQ+ youth are particularly vulnerable to conversion practices, especially within conservative families and religious communities. Early intervention through education can help shift attitudes and reduce the prevalence of these practices.
**Recommendations:**
- **Comprehensive sexuality education**: Advocate for the inclusion of LGBTQ+ topics in sexuality education curricula, promoting acceptance and understanding from an early age.
- **Youth-focused outreach**: Develop programs that provide young LGBTQ+ individuals with the resources and support needed to navigate hostile environments and avoid conversion practices.
**Online and Digital Platforms:**
Conversion practices are increasingly being promoted through digital platforms, particularly in conservative and religious online communities. Monitoring these platforms and holding tech companies accountable for the content they host is crucial.
**Recommendations:**
- **Monitoring online spaces**: Work with tech companies to monitor and remove content promoting conversion practices.
- **Digital advocacy campaigns**: Launch online awareness campaigns to counteract misinformation and raise awareness about the harms of conversion practices.
**Engaging with Religious and Cultural Leaders:**
Religious and cultural leaders hold significant influence in African communities. Engaging with these leaders to shift their views on LGBTQ+ identities is key to changing social norms and reducing the demand for conversion practices.
**Recommendations:**
- **Dialogue with religious leaders**: Organize forums and dialogues with religious leaders to educate them on LGBTQ+ issues and the harm caused by conversion practices.
- **Support progressive religious movements**: Promote and support religious leaders and movements that advocate for LGBTQ+ inclusion and acceptance.
**Economic and Societal Impacts of Conversion Practices:**
The societal and economic toll of conversion practices is often overlooked. These practices not only harm individuals but also contribute to broader societal problems, including increased healthcare costs and loss of workforce productivity.
**Recommendations:**
- **Economic arguments for change**: Highlight the economic costs of conversion practices, including the strain on mental health services and lost productivity.
- **Research and data collection**: Commission studies to quantify the financial and societal impact of conversion practices, providing policymakers with evidence-based arguments for reform.
**Conclusion:**
Ending conversion practices in Africa requires a comprehensive, multi-sectoral approach. Strategic litigation, combined with mental health support, international pressure, and engagement with religious and cultural leaders, will be critical to achieving this goal. Through collaborative efforts involving legal, health, and civil society actors, African nations can move toward a future where LGBTQ+ individuals are free from harmful and dehumanizing conversion practices.
Author,
Dean Bordode,
Human Rights’ Defender
Comments